We use cookies to provide you with the best possible website experience. This includes cookies that are necessary for the operation of the site, as well as cookies used for anonymous statistics, comfort settings, or displaying personalized content. You can decide which categories you want to allow. Please note that depending on your settings, some features of the website may not be available.

Cookie settings

These necessary cookies are required to enable the core functionality of the website. Opting out of these cookies is not possible.

cb-enable
This cookie stores the user's cookie consent status for the current domain. Expiry: 1 year.
laravel_session
Stores the session ID to recognize the user when the page reloads and to restore their login session. Expiry: 2 hours.
XSRF-TOKEN
Provides CSRF protection for forms. Expiry: 2 hours.
IZA Discussion Paper No. 19100
November 2026
Team Composition Matters for Overcoming Correlation Neglect in Belief Formation

Correlated signals are common in the information we process daily, and yet many people treat them as if they were independent, generating biased beliefs. Given that many important decisions are taken by teams, we study in an experiment with 410 participants whether team decision-making reduces this bias in comparison to individual decision making. At first sight, the answer is negative, at least in the aggregate, but closer inspection reveals that teams are less affected by correlation neglect and generate significantly higher earnings in the task. Most importantly, team composition matters crucially. Classifying team members as either naive (i.e., prone to correlation neglect) or rational, we show that having a rational partner halves a naive member’s naivete, and the share of tasks in which a pair states the rational belief rises from 9% with two naive members to 40% with one rational member and 67% with two. Pairs with one rational member are, on average, about as naive as rational individuals, yet they fall short of a demanding "truth-wins norm", according to which teams should make rational choices whenever at least one member is classified as rational. Our extensive analysis of team chats helps explain these patterns.

Kommunikation
Mark Fallak
mark.fallak@liser.lu
+352 585-855-526
World of Labour
Olga Nottmeyer
olga.nottmeyer-ext@liser.lu
+352 585-855-501
Netzwerkkoordination
Christina Gathmann
christina.gathmann@liser.lu

Das IZA@LISER-Netzwerk ist eine weltweite Gemeinschaft für exzellente Forschung in der Arbeitsmarktökonomie und angrenzenden Fachgebieten. Nach dem Wechsel von Bonn wird das Netzwerk nun am Luxembourg Institute of Socio-Economic Research (LISER) koordiniert.

Über das IZA@LISER Network
Contact
IZA@LISER NETWORK (Current Site Operator):

Luxembourg Institute of Socio-Economic Research (LISER)
11, Porte des Sciences
Maison des Sciences Humaines
L-4366 Esch-sur-Alzette / Belval, Luxembourg

IZA Institute (In Liquidation):

Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit GmbH i. L.
Schaumburg-Lippe-Str. 5-9, 53113 Bonn. Germany
Phone: +49 228 3894-0 | Fax: +49 228 3894-510
E-Mail: info@iza.org | Web: www.iza.org
Represented by: Martin T. Clemens (Liquidator)