%0 Report %A Monteiro, Sofia %A Praxmarer, Matthias %A Schmidt, Stefan %A Sutter, Matthias %T Team Composition Matters for Overcoming Correlation Neglect in Belief Formation %D 2026 %8 2026 Nov %I Institute of Labor Economics (IZA) %C Bonn %7 IZA Discussion Paper %N 19100 %U https://www.iza.org/publications/dp19100 %X Correlated signals are common in the information we process daily, and yet many people treat them as if they were independent, generating biased beliefs. Given that many important decisions are taken by teams, we study in an experiment with 410 participants whether team decision-making reduces this bias in comparison to individual decision making. At first sight, the answer is negative, at least in the aggregate, but closer inspection reveals that teams are less affected by correlation neglect and generate significantly higher earnings in the task. Most importantly, team composition matters crucially. Classifying team members as either naive (i.e., prone to correlation neglect) or rational, we show that having a rational partner halves a naive member’s naivete, and the share of tasks in which a pair states the rational belief rises from 9% with two naive members to 40% with one rational member and 67% with two. Pairs with one rational member are, on average, about as naive as rational individuals, yet they fall short of a demanding "truth-wins norm", according to which teams should make rational choices whenever at least one member is classified as rational. Our extensive analysis of team chats helps explain these patterns. %K beliefs %K correlation neglect %K bounded rationality %K team decision-making %K experiment